Collaborating with Kroka Final Presentation
Trevor McDonald and 3 OthersAri SinertIsa Murray
Schuyler Johnson + Privacy: Public
Ari Sinert, Isa Murray, Schuyler Johnson, Trevor McDonald
Final Presentation | 11.15.2023
Overview | Kroka Expeditions
In a wilderness setting, one always needs to be ready to adapt to the present moment. Kroka values the importance of a developed sense of intuition in combination with leadership skills. The four core principles of intuitive leadership are:
- Observing the world around us
- Working with the elemental forces
- Practicing skills for self-reliance
- Acknowledging the unseen world
Kroka's curriculum is centered around simplicity, authenticity, gratitude, and cooperation. As much as possible we source our food and gear locally, we engage with communities that we travel through, we value adaptation and mindful decision-making, and we encourage appropriate risk-taking.
-Kroka's Website
Overview | Vision
- Must fit the Kroka campus aesthetically
- Not allowed to use any electronics
- Must use Kroka materials
- Principles of Inefficient Design
Goals
- Communicate meaningfully with a client
- Create a lasting physical impact on a community
- Design something without electronics that can be built by hand
Design Constraints
Project Timeline
Visit #1
Initial Proposals
Project Pitch
Visit #2
Secondary Iterations
Zoom w/Client
Visit #3 (Overnight)
Final Presentation
Raising Boats
Efficient Cooking
Wood Drying
Visit #1 | Proposed Issues
Issue
Design Constraints
- Able to be operated by a single person
- Must include a locking mechanism
- $250 Budget
Boats at Kroka are stored in the boathouse. To pull boats up, two people at each end of the boat are needed and there is no locking mechanism.
Issue
Design Constraints
- Aesthetically beautiful
- Can hold three pots
- Durable
- Above Knee height
Most meals at Kroka camps require three pots, and currently, they don't have a stove that can do that while surviving the weather conditions at Kroka.
Issue
Design Constraints
- Fits with the Kroka campus
- Can be long term
- Doesn't have to be implemented immediately
Kroka goes through about 30 chords of wood a year and it is stored in large cylinders that are exposed to the elements. Floods and winters can often wipe out a lot of wood.
Visit #1 | Issue Analysis
Proposal #1 | Pulley System
System 1 - 7:1 w/Winch - 28:1
System 2 - 2:1 w/Winch - 8:1
System 3 - 4:1 w/Winch - 16:1
Mechanical Advantage
Proposal #2 | Rocket Stove
Proposal #3 | Kiln Research
- Current moisture content of wood pre-drying = aprox. 35%
- Moisture content post dry = aprox. 15%
- Estimated content post kiln dry = 8-10%
- Wood circles: 330 ft^3 = aprox. 2.5 cords of wood.
- Farmhouse winter storage = 920 ft^3 = aprox. 7.2 cords of wood
- Summer camp storage = 950 ft^3 = aprox. 7.4 cords of wood
- It takes 6-12 months to dry black cherry wood to a moisture content of 15%.
- With a solar kiln, it would take 4-6 weeks. That's a 1200% increase in time efficiency.
- Solar kilns reduce moisture content to 8-10%, an increase of 30% efficiency in moisture content.
- Solar kiln dried wood is 10-25% more carbon efficient compared to traditionally dried wood.
Underlying Research
Major Takeaways
Blueprints for Solar Kiln
Post-Proposal Changes
Raising Boats
Efficient Cooking
Wood Drying
Result
Next Steps
- Prepare to install pulley system
- Create risk assessment framework
Kroka is satisfied with the proposed pulley system, and is excited to see the effectiveness of the implemented system.
Result
Next Steps
- Continue to research & brainstorm stove ideas
- Prepare for site analysis
Kroka is on board with the creation of a rocket stove on it's campus. During our second visit, they will show us two potential sites and the available materials.
Result
Next Steps
- Because creating a solar kiln is no longer possible, it is no longer a critical priority
- Continue background research
Kroka is open to building a solar kiln in the future, but is unable to physically commit to such a large-scale project presently.
Visit #2 | Overview
Overview
After our first visit, we had finished a pulley system plan, and started brainstorming for a final rocket stove prototype. In order to progress our rocket stove prototype, we needed to find and assess available materials as well as potential sites.
Objectives
- Install pulley system prototype
- Assess potential sites for rocket stove
- Assess available materials for rocket stove
Visit #2 | Pulley Implementation
Visit #2 | Stove Site Analysis
Site 1 - Pizza Oven Location
Site 2 - Staff Village
Pros -
- Easy access for summer camp
- Close to other major stovetop
Cons -
- Harder for year-round staff to access
- Close to other major stovetop
Pros -
- Easy access for year-round staff
- Contributes to current Kroka project-staff kitchen
Cons -
- Harder for summer camp staff to access
- Sloped building surface
Visit #2 | Material Analysis
Available Materials
Material Constraints
- Bricks are not uniform size
- Slight damage to cinderblocks, bricks
- Limited number of flagstones, not enough to build a base
- Cinderblocks
- Gravel/dirt
- Bricks (some believed to be fire-resistant)
- Flagstones / masonry stones
- Ceramic Tiles
Visit #3 | Overnight Stay
Overview
Having finished our first pulley prototype, we were eager to improve and finalize it. In addition, the schematics for the rocket stove were complete. Our third visit was planned over two days, where we would help with farm chores alongside our project work.
Objectives
- Install pulley system prototype
- Assist Kroka with chores and daily tasks over the span of multiple days
Visit #3 | Life At Kroka
Visit #3 | Life At Kroka
Visit #3 | Fixing Pulleys
Visit #3 | Stove Construction
Conclusion & Analysis
Raising Boats
Efficient Cooking
Wood Drying
Result
Next Steps
- Continue to increase gear ratio
- Add progress-capture device
The pulley system and wench were installed successfully. Currently, the gear ratio is 8:1, allowing one person to raise the boat. The current prototype is missing a progress capture device.
Result
Next Steps
- Research & order proper materials
Due to the lack of heat-resistant material we were unable to create a permanent structure. Created working prototype with the available materials.
Result
Next Steps
- Continue to research solar kiln designs
- Create final design scale
Kroka is open to building a solar kiln in the future, but is unable to commit to such a large-scale project presently.
Final Reflections
Reflections
Skills Built
- Client Interaction
- Project Framing & Scope
- Project Management
- Time Management
- Risk Management
- Scheduling & Efficient Workflow
- Final, Physical Deleverables!
- Permanent construction takes a long time!
- Mortar is difficult to use without proper equipment
- Long distance workflow is a challenge